10 Ways To Leverage Social Proof in Your Cold Email Messages To Boost Engagement

by Vinny Hassan in September 21st, 2022
cover image/person using laptop

Social proof is a psychological phenomenon that occurs when people look to the actions and behaviors of others to determine their own. In other words, if we see that others are doing something, we are more likely to do it ourselves. This concept can be leveraged in cold email messages to boost engagement and increase the chances of getting a response.

Here are 10 ways to leverage social proof in your cold email messages:

Mention mutual connections

Leveraging social proof in your cold email messages can be an effective tactic for building relationships. Going a step further and mentioning mutual connections with the recipient can create a different level of trust between you, as they'll know that you have shared links with someone familiar to them.

Plus, this approach can make the email seem more personable, making them more likely to respond to your message -- so take advantage of this opportunity!

Use testimonials

Writing a successful cold email is tricky. You want to grab the attention of your intended recipient, and one way to do that is by leveraging social proof. One way to demonstrate value is by including testimonials from prior customers or clients.

This helps build credibility and can even encourage a response to your message. Try adding some quotes or short feedback pieces on how you have helped others in the past. It's a great way to showcase the success of working with you while simultaneously enticing the reader to reach out and start a conversation.

For example, you could include a sentence like, “Some of our clients have seen a 10% increase in website traffic after working with us.” Something like this can be a powerful statement that will pique your recipient's interest.

Share social media following

Adding social proof to your cold email can be valuable to building trust with potential customers. Nothing speaks louder than an impressive social media following when demonstrating your credibility. If you’ve successfully grown your network through sites like Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, and Instagram, be sure to mention this fact in your email messages.

This will help to show prospective customers that others have liked or followed what you have shared -- giving them instant peace of mind when considering whether or not they should purchase from you.

white smartphone on green grass

Image source


Leveraging social proof in your messages is a practical approach that can help increase response rates. That’s why including links to press mentions of your company or product can be powerful—it shows potential customers that you have the trust of others. It establishes your reputation as a go-to provider in the industry.

Whether it’s a major publication featuring you or smaller blogs citing your products, take advantage of any press coverage and use it as part of your cold email campaigns.

For example, you could include a sentence like, “Our product has been featured in the New York Times and ABC News.” This is a great way to grab someone’s attention and establish your credibility as an expert.

Use logos of well-known companies

Adding logos of well-known companies is an effective way to demonstrate social proof when crafting a cold email message. A visual representation of your experience working with these organizations helps make a strong impression on potential customers and reveals the level of expertise they can expect from you.

Leveraging this imagery throughout your cold messages is an easy and impactful way to establish credibility and increase response rates.

Share industry awards

A simple and effective tactic to use social proof within your cold email messages is to mention any awards your business or products have won. This will help build credibility with readers and show that others in the same industry have acknowledged the quality and value behind your offering.

Make sure to shout about any awards you've won in your emails and start to see a positive impact when it comes to getting those emails responded to.

For example, you could add a sentence like, “We’ve been recently awarded the Industry Leader Award for our innovative approach to customer service.” This type of statement will quickly grab the reader's attention and help demonstrate that you can deliver great results.

Mention industry influencers

Mention industry influencers that you have connections with. It can help establish your credibility and show potential customers or contacts that these individuals have taken an interest in what you are offering. This proof goes a long way in creating trust from those who may be hesitant to engage with someone they don't know.

When used strategically, references to influencers help elevate a cold email message and give recipients cause to pay attention and take action.

shallow focus photography of crowd taking video

Image source


Include customer numbers

Mentioning influencers in your industry, especially if you have a connection with them, can be a great way to get noticed and establish credibility with potential customers. This shows that respected figures in the industry are interested in what you have to offer, which will make those prospects more likely to engage with you as well.

Ensure you're always respectful and cognizant of any pre-existing relationships with these influencers before mentioning them in your message.

Share case studies

Having case studies to back up the effectiveness of your product or service can be a great way to get the attention of prospects in your cold emails. Outlining concrete examples of how your offering made a difference to someone else's business shows that you know what you're talking about and can offer real value, making it easier for your potential customers to trust you.

When adding case studies to your cold emails, make sure you include specific details and don’t skimp on results to maximize the impact of this powerful social proof.

Use social media buttons

Incorporating social media buttons into your initial cold email contact is easy to establish credibility and demonstrate that you're a reliable source of information. It lets the recipient know that you already have an active presence on social media and that they can connect with you directly there.

Having a few links to your different accounts can give an additional layer of trustworthiness, make it easier for them to contact you, and help them feel more comfortable responding back. All this adds up to giving your mail messages an effective boost in engagement.

Last reflections

Overall, using social proof in your cold email messages can be a powerful tool to boost engagement and increase the chances of getting a response. By leveraging mutual connections, testimonials, press mentions, industry awards, and other forms of social proof, you can establish your credibility and show that others are interested in your offering.

This can build trust and increase the likelihood of a successful outcome. So, start using social proof in your cold emails today and begin to see results.

Your cart
    Checkout